BOOKS: There and Back Again
Every once and awhile I stop blathering about my work and bow down to the many book titles that had a tremendous impact on my developing imagination and ability as a Kid Artist with Big Dreams.
Like most of the literate world, I adored J.R.R. Tolkien’s first foray into Middle-Earth when I read The Hobbit back in middle school. To me, it was an epic tale that I devoured like a hungry troll in between my games of Dungeons & Dragons and Adventure on my Atari 2600. My reality as a pimply lollipop-headed geek disappeared each time I slipped on the ring, opened my dog-eared tome, and plunged into the wilderwood of hobbits, elves, dwarves and dragons.
What I didn’t grasp then, is that the copy I read contained drawings by that Gandalf of great storytelling himself. I adored Tolkien’s decorative, almost Kay Nielsen-esque, images of Hobbiton, the Trolls and the mighty Smaug.
Tolkien’s images were further brought to life in the 1977 made-for-TV animated film adaptation done by none other than the holiday-celebrated-stop-motion messiahs, Arthur Rankin and Jules Bass.
The Rankin & Bass rendition of The Hobbit not only galvanized my neverending storybook love of all of Middle Earth, it took it to new heights with its Arthur Rackhamy watercolor backgrounds, somewhat-grotesque character designs and sinister songs.
Here’s a couple of scans from the book adaptation of the film. (Click for a larger view)
Yes, to some this version may not hold up, but I feel that this adaptation of the story lured in a new generation of young hobbits ready for more adventures. And the nostalgia for the Rankin & Bass film absolutely affected my drawing style as can be seen by this 1997 cover to Dragon magazine.
After I graduated art school, I came across Michael Kaluta’s outstanding work done for the 1994 Tolkien Calendar. A calendar!? This phenomenal work should have been put in a leather bound re-illustrated book of its own! Sigh…someday.
I still fondly remember spending a rainy afternoon in Michael’s cramped-n-cozy toy-filled studio in the Upper West Side and begging him to pull out the originals for this which he reluctantly obliged. As I looked through these ink-and-watercolor masterpieces I was quickly overwhelmed with a wave of inspiration and a caustic dose of artistic ineptitude. To this day, Kaluta’s passionate visions of Middle Earth are the work of true wizardry.
A few years later, I actually got to add a little to the Tolkien universe myself(!) when the art director for Del Rey books rang me up to ask if I’d be interested illustrating a new cover for Tolkien’s Unfinished Tales. (Actually when he called, It was one of the few times in my life where I thought I would pass out on the other end of the telephone).
Needless to say, I put my best hairy hobbit foot forward and strove for a unique pic of Bilbo Baggins reading through Tolkien’s handwritten manuscripts. I am pretty sure the Tolkien estate approved this image, so it was a nice day at the DiTerlizzi shire when copies of this gem arrived on my hobbit hole doorstep.
The impact of Tolkien’s magic world still reverberates with me to this day as I am sure it does with many. I re-read The Hobbit last spring in between drafts of The Search for WondLa to see how he handled the passage of time during the journey. (In fact, the camping scene in Chapter 19 was added after the reading). Lastly, I saw how Tolkien was credited on the title page and borrowed the same wording for mine. Though I have penned several picture books a chapter book, and helped plot Spiderwick, WondLa was the first time I truly felt like an author.
Thanks, John, may you continue to inspire and entertain as you journey to the Undying Lands of the West.
Here is a photo of Tolkien’s original artwork done for the first edition. It is rendered in pencil, black ink, watercolor and white gouache. Houghton Mifflin Books for Children still offers a facsimile edition of this. (Click for a larger view)
Update: This blog feeds into my facebook page where there has also been some great reminisces going on as well. As I mentioned there, I would be remiss if I didn’t mention Michael Hague’s rendition or the Brother’s Hildebrandt. In fact, those calendars the Hildebrandt’s did were right up there with the original Star Wars poster in epic awesomeness.
Lastly, I found this wonderful sketch from a proposal by Maurice Sendak done back in 1967. As far as I can gather, he was to meet with Tolkien to discuss an illustrated edition, but suffered a heart attack(!) and the project never came to be…sigh.















I love that Tolkien cover. With the road seemingly leading directly from the Shire to the Lonely Mountain, it really encapsulates the sentiment of this:
“It’s a dangerous business, Frodo, going out of your door. You step onto the Road, and if you don’t keep your feet, there is no knowing where you might be swept off to.”
Oh man does this take me back. I too devoured anything Tolkien, and wanted desperately to one day illustrate for a Tolkien calendar. My favorite illustrators at the time, were the Hildebrandt brothers, and actually your illustration of Bilbo reminds me a bit of their style. I think I would have died right there if someone ever called to ask me to do an illustration of anything Middle Earth. Alas I finally decided I wasn’t a “great” illustrator, and couldn’t settle for mediocrity, so I went down other paths. But there is still that pull after all these years.
S’funny you should mention that, because I just read the David Wenzel, Charles Dixon & Sean Deming comic book of The Hobbit yesterday.
http://mordicai.livejournal.com/1861739.html
Reading through posts such as these is always so inspiring, I need to stop faffing about and work on my portfolio!
I never imagined Bilbo to look that ugly (like in the animated film). More like… well, more like Martin Freeman, really.
What a wonderful review of Hobbit illustrations. Has the OneRing.net found your post yet? Agree about Martin Freeman.
Tony- I linked to your blog from the One Ring site, and thoroughly enjoyed your post. I met you years ago at a GenCon in Milwaukee,when a friend was publishing RPGs and I got dragooned into writing for him. I was overwhelmed with your artistic talent and hoped you would have greater success, and I’m very pleased to see that this has come to be. As soon as I saw art from the “Spiderwick Chronicles,” I recognized it as your work. Had I known you had the same love for Middle Earth as I do, I probably would have talked your ear off about it, and asked you to draw me a Dunedain Ranger, to boot.
Thanks for adding the link, Buck, I appreciate it. And thanks for being a fan all these years. I have some other hobbit sketches that I’ll have to post…
Man, that painting just stirred something in my heart. Imagine a lonely little boy, circa 1981, sitting in his room with Tolkien calendar pictures plastering his walls, 5 different editions of the books scoured from used bookstores, D & D manuals and Ral Partha lead figurines, an old wingback chair from Goodwill, and me–13 years old–sitting and reading Tolkien with a longstemmed pipe clamped between my teeth. My little oasis.
Thanks for posting this blog. Cheers.
Nice memory, Noble. I would have been 12 and I would have come over and played D&D with you:)
Absolutely wonderful illustrations, they really bring the story to life. Can anyone tell me if this book by Rankin/Bass illustrating is still available to purchase, i tried finding it on Amazon but havn’t been fortunate so far.
The book is long out of print I am afraid to say, Shelley. However, there are quite a few listed on eBay. It is the complete text illustrated by stills and production art from the film and a real treasure if you enjoyed the film as I did.
Tony, What a wonderful article. I had the 1984 calendar on my wall as soon as it came out. That is till my favorite Legolas after all these years and Kaluta’s Aragorn and Arwen is fantastic also.
It’s funny how closely everyone’s stories are so simillar. I had the used books, the clumsily painted lead figures, the thumbtacked posters everywhere and even the pipe clenched between my teeth (filled with tobacco stolen from my father’s cigarettes). I remember passing notes to my friends in class written in anglo-saxon runes and laughing silently whenever our teacher snatched one up to try and read it.
Thanks for a great article that takes me back to those years.
PS- I never knew you were the Illustrator of that cover of Unfinished Tales! I already had 4 different editions of that book when I saw it on the shelf at Barnes & Noble. I loved your artwork so much I bought a 5th copy on the spot- tell your publisher…
Thanks Rick, I am a sucker for nostalgia meself.
Tony thank you for this blog ( I found the link on the onering.net). I have loved Tolkien since I was a kid and I also am a huge fan of Michael Kaluta but somehow I never knew he had done a Tolkein calendar! How did I miss that? The images are beautiful. Thanks for the link.
PS-just picked up Wondla. Looking forward to it even more now.
Great blog. I still have a very battered copy of the Rankin Bass book around somewhere. I remember reading to my younger brother chapter by chapter as a a bedtime story over a couple of months. He must have been only 6 or 7 but he loved it and would go to school the next day and at recess re-enact the previous night’s story for all his friends.
Yours is the paperback edition of UNFINISHED TALES that I own – but I never noticed the typewriter in the background before! I need to dig it out and see if it was cropped out of the final cover…
Honestly, I’m not that surprised. I recently read THE HOBBIT aloud to my 9-year-old daughter and we’re working through FELLOWSHIP now, and it seems like the hobbits are a little more technologically advanced than the rest of Middle-Earth, especially when it comes to work- and time-saving mechanisms. (Many hobbits left Bilbo’s Party via carriage, not on foot.)
We have spent many a happy hour dining in the Hobbit House, Manila, and enejyod the music there and the delightfully friendly staff. I bought a sun visor from there (black with Hobbit House motif) and have since lost it.Would love another one! Any chance you could send me one, and I’ll reimburse?We are now living back in the UK, so can’t collect myself.Sheila Selwyn